Hidden issues and challenges of the concept and use of water productivity index

Document Type : Review

Author

Associate Professor, Irrigation and Drainage Dep. AERI Institute

Abstract

The water productivity index (WP), which is defined as the crop produced per unit of consumed water, has been considered as a key indicator for the optimal use of water in the agricultural sector. It has been heavily relied upon in the Iran's agricultural water policies and plans. However despite several years have passed since the introduction of this concept and index, unfortunately, water crisis still exists and is expanding in the country and measures to increase WP in agricultural products have not yet been able to effectively solve the country's water issues. In this review-analytical paper, the issues and challenges of using this index in practice have been discussed and the shortcomings, challenges, measures, and infrastructure necessary for the proper use of this index have been discussed and analyzed. According to the results, there are hidden issues and challenges (in 8 groups) in its application. The most important of which are the need to deeply understand the concept and definition of WP in the country's expert and management community, and the problems and issues of using the index from the aspect of lack of the required infrastructure for the proper impacts of improving WP in mitigating water scarcity. According to the identified issues and challenges, it was concluded that improving WP could not be a sole measure to solve the country's water crisis, because it fulfills just initial conditions. In order to fulfill conditions sufficiently and to implement related comprehensive measures and interventions, the necessary hardware, software, legal, and policy infrastructures must be provided.

Keywords


Hidden issues and challenges of the concept and use of water productivity

EXTENDED ABSTRACT

Introduction

The water productivity index (WP), which is defined as the crop produced per unit of consumed water, was launched in the world with the aim of reducing water consumption and allocating more water to the environment. In compliance with that, this theoretical concept and index has presented itself in the literature and even in the macro-level laws and documents and development plans of Iran. Therefore, it has been considered as a key measure and indicator in the optimal use of water in the agricultural sector, and has been heavily relied upon in the Iran's agricultural water policies and plans.

However despite several years have passed since the introduction of this concept and index, unfortunately, water crisis still exists and is expanding in the country and measures to increase WP in agriculture have not yet been able to effectively solve the country's water scarcity issues.

There are various issues and challenge in use of concepts and indicators explaining the optimal and efficient use of water in practice, and they should not be relied on without the necessary studies and evaluations. Therefore, the objective of this review-analytical paper is to investigate and analyze the hidden issues and challenges of the WP index in its practical use with the aim of managing and mitigating agricultural water crisis in Iran.

Materials and Methods

The research method is mainly based on collecting and reviewing international and national scientific literature related to the subject, use of the national results and statistics, macro-level national laws and documents, experiences and opinions of the experts, together with the required analysis and discussions.

This review-analytical paper deals with the problems and challenges of using the WP index in practice. Therefore shortcomings, challenges, arrangements, and necessary infrastructure for the optimal use of this concept and index have been discussed and analyzed.

Results and Discussion

According to the results, the WP index has hidden problems and challenges in its application in practice. These include: 1) The need to properly understand the concept and definition of WP in the water and agriculture experts and management community of the country, 2)The problems and issues of using the index from the aspect of lack of the required infrastructure for the proper impacts of improving WP in mitigating water scarcity, 3) Real and correct understanding of the concept from the aspects of the existence of internal relationship between the numerator and the denominator of the index and the correct selection of relevant solutions for the effectiveness of the activities and interventions, 4) Weaknesses in in index in regard to defining WP in conditions out of human management in the production of agricultural products, 5) Issues and challenges related to comparing the results of WP values ​​in different biophysical, geographical, and management conditions, 6) The challenge of choosing productivity approaches. i.e. physical or economic WP and choosing the optimal national index for water management and choosing the appropriate cropping pattern, 7) The challenge of choosing a management scale and the issues of determining WP at the basin scale, and 8) The existence of flaws and shortcomings in the WP index itself in terms of its comprehensiveness to apply it as an index.

Conclusion

In response to the question whether improving WP can be a fundamental solution to solve the Iran's water scarcity and save the country from this crisis, it must be acknowledged that the answer depends on the difficult choices that policymakers have to make regarding water resources, as well as the provision of necessary hardware, software, legal and policy infrastructures for the related comprehensive solutions and interventions which includes: volume delivery of water, water accounting, preventing the expansion of cultivated area, preventing the changing of the copping pattern to water-intensive crops, updating laws and creating the necessary executive guarantees for the implementation of approved laws, comprehensiveness and having a regional and national perspective, taking into account the participation of the stakeholders, and providing the necessary financial resources. Accomplishing these criteria is very complicated due to the diverse goals and interests of different actors and the various scales and systems in which the use of agricultural water is placed, and doing all of them may not be practical in the short term.

Considering the hidden issues and challenges mentioned, improving WP could not be a sole measure to solve the country's water crisis, because it fulfills just initial conditions. In order to fulfill conditions sufficiently and to implement related comprehensive measures and interventions, the necessary hardware, software, legal, and policy infrastructures also must be provided.

 

Ahmad, M.U.D., Islam M.D. A., Masih I., Muthuwatta L. Karimi P., & Turral H. (2009). Mapping basin-level water productivity using remote sensing and secondary data in the Karkheh River Basin, Iran, Water International, 34:1,119–133, DOI: 10.1080/02508060802663903.
Azizi Zohan A.A., Liaghat, A. M., & Shahabi Far, K. (2019). Definition and specification of water productivity management index and its application for fodder Maize in Moghan Plain, Journal of Water Research in Agriculture (Soil and Water Sci.) 33 (4), 519-534. (in Persian)
Berbel, J., Gutierrez-Martin, C., Rodriguez-Diaz, J.A., Camacho, E. & Montesinos, P. (2015) Literature review on rebound effect of water saving measures and analysis of a Spanish case study, Water Resources Management, 29:663–678.
Baghani, J., Abbasi, M., Dehghanian, S.A., Moqbali Doman, A., Zulfiqaran, A., Guderzi, M., Moayeri, M.; Sabki, A., Zare Mehrani, A, Karimi, M., Ayin, A., Lotfian, B., Ebrahimi, R., Saidi, G., Naseri, A., Miri, Kh., Hosseini, Y., Alian Ghayathi, A., Hedayatipour, A., Najmi, M., Taheri, M., Hassan Balochi, M., Hajbi, A.H., Abbasi, F., Abbasi, N., Nakhjavani Moghadam, M. M., Akbari, M., Ghafari Asl, Z., Tajik, F., & Mousavi Fazl, S.H. (2021). Determining the water applied for watermelon in the Iran. Final research report no. 60318, Agricultural Engineering Research Institute, Karaj, Iran. (in Persian)
Baghani, J., Moayeri, M., Verjavand, P., Salah, N., Eslami, A., Shahrukhnia, M.A., Kiani, A.R., Gadami Firouzabadi, A., Haghayeghi Moghadam, A., Khosravi, H.,; Akhvan, K., Bahramlou, R., Naseri, A., Abbasi, F., Akbari, M.; Abbasi, N., Mousavifazl, S.H., Taiferezaei, H., Hosseinzadeh Ajirlou, S.; Ghafari Asl, Z., Aghaei, M.J., Dehghanian, S.A.; Yusef-Gomrakchi, A., Moqbli-Damaneh, A., Eslami, A.R., Nakhjavani-Moghadam, M.M., & Nemati, Sh. (2018). Determining the water consumption of wheat in the Iran, Final Research Report, No. 53636, Agricultural Engineering Research Institute, Karaj, Iran (in Persian).
Bagheri, A. (1400). The letter of Dr. Ali Bagheri, Associate Professor of Water Engineering and Management Department, Tarbiat Modares University to the President, the news published in Sharq newspaper, news code 296279, Thursday, August 8, 2021. (in Persian)
Bessembinder, J.J.E., Leffelaar, P.A., Dhindwal, A.S., & Ponsioen, T.C. (2005). Which crop and which drop, and the scope for improvement of water productivity, Agricultural Water Management, 73, 113–130.
Chamber of Commerce.(2023). Presentation of the results of the national plan for measuring the water consumption of various agricultural and horticultural crops, meeting of the working group on agriculture and water, National Center for Strategic Studies of Agriculture and Water, Commerce Chamber of Industries-Mines-Agriculture of Iran, Sep. 27, 2023, Tehran, Iran (in Persian).
Expediency Council. (2010). Evaluation of indicators of general policies of the Iran in water management: Volume 15 - Key indicators of quantification and evaluation of general policies of the Iran, Infrastructure Commission of the Expediency Council, Secretariat of the Expediency Council, July 2010, Tehran. 67 p. (in Persian).
Giordano, M.A., Rijsberman, F., & Maria Saleth, R.( 2006). More crop per drop: Revisiting a research paradigm: Results and synthesis of IWMI's Research 1996-2005. Book, Feb., 2006, International Water Management Institute, Colombo, Sri Lanka, ISBN: 1843391120.
Giordano, M., H. Turral, S. M. Scheierling, D. O. Tréguer, & McCornick. P. G. (2017). Beyond “More Crop per Drop”: Evolving Thinking on Agricultural Water Productivity, IWMI Research Report 169. Colombo, Sri Lanka: International Water Management Institute, and Washington, DC: World Bank.
Gleick, P.H., Christian-Smith, J., & Cooley, H. (2011). Water-use efficiency and productivity: rethinking the basin approach, Water International, 36(7): 784–798, doi.org/10.1080/02508060.2011.631873.
Heydari, N. (2014). Water productivity in agriculture: challenges in concepts, terms and values, Irrig. and Drain. 63: 22–28, DOI: 10.1002/ird.1816.
Heydari, N. (2019).Challenges and measures of improving livestock water productivity. Technical Report no. 56237, Agricultural Engineering Research Institute, 35 p. (in Persian)
Heydari, N. (2022). Wheat water productivity in Iran compared with data of some countries. Journal of Water Research in Agriculture (Soil and Water Sci.), 35 (4), 421-435. (in Persian)
Heydari, N., Dehghanisanij, H. & Alaei Tafti, M. (2017). Management of agricultural water demand and use in Iran. Book, Iranian National Committee on Irrigation and Drainage (IRNCID), Pub. No. 169, ISBN: 978-964-6668-99-7, 292 p. (in Persian)
Israelsen, O.W. (1950). Irrigation principles and practices,. Wiley, New York, p 471.
Kiani, M..(2023). Water reallocation and the Iran's water road map, the speech of engineer Milad Kiani, the head of the water resources planning department of the Iran's Water Resources Management Company, a joint meeting on water reallocation, the working group on agriculture and water, National Center for Strategic Studies of Agriculture and Water, Commerce Chamber of Industries-Mines-Agriculture of Iran, Aug. 7, 2023, Tehran, Iran (in Persian)
Mohammad Wali Samani, J. & Mazaheri, M. (2009) Water productivityin the agricultural sector. Water Group, Infrastructure Studies Office, Islamic Council Research Center, Subject code 250, Serial number 9912, Sep. 2009, 20 p. (in Persian).
Molden, D. (1997). Accounting for water use and productivity. In: SWIM Paper 1, IIMI, Colombo.
Molden, D., Oweis, T., Steduto, P., Bindraban, P., Hanjra, M. A. & Kijne, J. (2010). Improving Agricultural Water Productivity: Between Optimism and Caution, Agricultural Water Management, Comprehensive Assessment of Water Management in Agriculture, 97 (4): 528–35. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.agwat.2009.03.023.
Molden, D., Murray-Rust, H., Sakthivadivel, R., & Makin, I. (2003). A water-productivity framework for understanding and action. In: Kijne, J.W., Barker, R., & Molden, D. (Eds.), Water Productivity in Agriculture: Limits and Opportunities for Improvement, Comprehensive Assessment of Water Management in Agriculture Series 1. CABI/IWMI, Wallingford/Colombo, pp. 1–18.
Molden, D. & Sakthivadivel, R. (1999). Water accounting to assess use and productivity of water. Water Resources Development, 15, 55–71.
Mousavi Fazl, S.H. Rahimian, M.H. Koohi, N., Riahi, H., Keramati, M. Abbasi, F., & Baghani, J. (2021). Evaluation of irrigation water application and productivity of pistachio in the main producer regions of Iran (Kerman, Khorasan Razavi, Yazd and Semnan Provinces). Iranian Journal of Irrigation and Drainage, 14 (6), 2244-2256. (in Persian).
Murray-Rust, H., Droogers. P., & Heydari, N.  (2004). Water for the future: Linking Irrigation and water allocation in the Zayandeh Rud Basin, Iran. IWMI, Colombo, Sri Lanka, ISBN:92-9090-586-7.
Perry, C. (2007). Efficient irrigation; inefficient communication; flawed recommendations. Irrigation and Drainage, vol. 56. Wiley InterScience, pp. 367–378., DOI: 10.1002/ird.323.
Perry, C. (2011). Accounting for water use: Terminology and implications for saving water and increasing production, Agricultural Water Management, 98,pp. 1840–1846.
Perry, C., Steduto, P., Allen,  R.G. & Burt, CM. (2009). Increasing productivity in irrigated agriculture: agronomic constraints and hydrological realities. Agricultural Water Management, 96, pp. 1517–1524.
Pretty, C. (2010). The top 100 questions of importance to the future of global agriculture. International Journal of Agricultural Sustainability 8(4): 219–236, doi:10.3763/ijas.2010.0534, www.earthscan.co.uk/journals/ijas.
Perry, C. (2018). Improving irrigation management in conditions of scarcity: Myth vs Truth. Global Water Forum www.globalwaterforum.org, Oct.1 , 2018, 8 p.
Scheierling, S. M. & Tréguer, D.O. (2018). Beyond crop per drop: Assessing agricultural water productivity and efficiency in a maturing water economy, International Development in Focus. Washington, DC: World Bank. Doi:10.1596/978-1-4648-1298-9, License: Creative Commons Attribution CC BY 3.0 IGO.
Taheri, M., Rezaverdinejad, V., Behmanesh, J., Abbasi, F., & Baghani, J. (2020). Spatial analysis of water productivity index at major wheat production centers of Iran. Journal of Water Research in Agriculture (Soil and Water Sci.) 34 (2), 217-227. (in Persian)
US Interagency Task Force. (1979). Irrigation Water Use and Management. US Gov’t. Printing Office: Washington DC, USA; 143 pp.
Viets, F.G. (1966). Increasing water use efficiency by soil management. In Plant environment and efficient water use, ed. W.H. Pierre et al. Madison, Wisconsin, USA: American Society of Agronomy.
Water and food security meeting. (2017). Water and food security in five-year development plans. Summary of the meeting on water and food security in five-year development plans, Presidential Strategic Research Center  in collaboration with Islamic Council Research Center and Water Engineering Research Institute of Tarbiat Modares University, Nov., 21, 2017, Tehran. Center for Presidential Strategic Studies. 5 p. (in Persian)
Wichelns, D. (2015). Water productivity and food security: considering more carefully the farm-level perspective. Food Security. 7:247-260.
Workshop on reallocation of water.(2023). Report of the workshop on water re-allocation, the working group on agriculture and water, National Center for Strategic Studies of Agriculture and Water, Commerce Chamber of Industries-Mines-Agriculture of Iran, Aug. 8, 2023, Tehran, Iran (in Persian)
Xu, H., Yang, R. & Song, J. (2021) Agricultural water use efficiency and rebound effect: A study for China. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 18:7151-7160.
Yazdani, M.R., Taddidalab, K.; Hosseini, M., Ebadi, A.A., Elah Qalipour, M., Majidi, F.; Shokri Vahad, H., Allameh, A.R,; Causi, M., Shahdi, A.A., Asadi, R. Rezaei, M., Soltani, Sh., Yacoubi, B., Yousefi, R., Khokhdaman, M, Shahbazi, H, Adibi, Sh., & Alipour, F. (2021). Executive technical manual for improving water productivity in rice agriculture, Iran Rice Research Institute. registration in the Information Technology and Agricultural Information Center under number 9569 dated May, 31, 2021, 51 p. (in Persian)
Yu, W., Uhlenbrook, S., von Gnechten, R., & van der Bliek, J. (2021). Can water productivity improvements save us from global water scarcity? White paper 1. FAO. Rome, 41 p.