Iranian Journal of Soil and Water Research

Iranian Journal of Soil and Water Research

Strategies of Improving Agricultural Water Consumption in Qorveh and Dehgolan Plains (In Kurdistan Province)

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors
1 Department of Agricultural Management and Development, Faculty of Agricultural Economics and development, University of Tehran, Iran
2 Department of Agricultural Management and Development, Faculty of Agricultural Economics and development, University of Tehran,
Abstract
Due to the high level of water consumption in the agricultural sector, improving water use efficiency is considered a key factor in achieving agricultural development goals. Kurdistan Province, located in western Iran, despite having a cold climate, has faced water scarcity and an imbalance between water supply and demand over the past two decades, particularly in its eastern plains of Qorveh and Dehgolan (water code 1308). Given that agriculture is the primary water-consuming sector, this study was conducted with the aim of proposing strategies to improve water use and reduce the impacts of water scarcity on agricultural lands, using a qualitative approach and the SWOT technique. The required data were collected through questionnaires administered to 75 local experts from governmental and private organizations. To assess the internal and external environment of water consumption management in the study area, 98 sub-components were identified and analyzed as strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and threats. After calculating the relative importance, assigning weights to each sub-component, and scoring the evaluation matrix of internal and external factors, the findings indicated that the primary and priority strategy for improving water consumption falls within the ST (competitive strategy) category. To prioritize the identified strategies, opinions were obtained from ten experts. The results show that weaknesses and threats in the internal and external environments outweigh strengths and opportunities; however, overall, the positive strategic space is greater than the negative space. Among the 14 extracted strategies, seven were identified as top priorities for improving agricultural water resources and consumption in the study area: implementation of an adaptive cropping pattern, formulation of a comprehensive water plan, reform of the water allocation model, development of modern training programs, on-farm water storage, improvement of farm management, and smart irrigation. Therefore, the adoption of adaptive cropping patterns, managerial interventions in farm administration, and reform of water allocation management are strongly recommended.
Keywords
Subjects

Introduction

Kurdistan Province, located in the Zagros region in western Iran, comprises 18 hydrological units. In recent years, signs of water scarcity have been observed in several parts of the province. One of these hydrological units, coded 1308 and situated in the plains of Qorveh and Dehgolan, is currently facing water scarcity and an imbalance between water supply and demand. At first glance, Kurdistan Province appears to possess integrated and cohesive primary production resources in the agricultural sector and may not seem vulnerable to natural hazards or water shortages. However, empirical evidence suggests otherwise. There is a significant disparity between the eastern and western parts of the province in terms of water and soil resources. According to official reports from the Kurdistan Management and Planning Organization (2021), 86% of the province’s agricultural land, but only 17% of its water resources, are located in the eastern part. In contrast, the western part contains 14% of the agricultural land but holds 87% of the relatively abundant water resources, which are largely inaccessible due to steep slopes and limited arable land. Furthermore, based on the Standardized Precipitation–Evapotranspiration Index (SPEI), which is used to measure drought intensity, most counties in Kurdistan Province have experienced drought over the past decade (National Drought Monitoring Center, Iran Meteorological Organization, 2023). More than 90% of the area of Qorveh and Dehgolan counties—the focus of this study—has been affected by drought conditions.

The water scarcity situation in the study area has led governmental authorities to declare the plains of Qorveh and Dehgolan prohibited zones for the reallocation of water to both agricultural and non-agricultural activities over the past two decades. The consequences of the water crisis have included a decline in groundwater levels, saline water intrusion, and increased risks to agricultural lands and crop water supply.

Since 2005, the Ministry of Energy has implemented the Groundwater Balance Plan in Kurdistan Province through 15 projects. Under the Water Adaptation Plan for the target years 2025–2026 (1404–1405 in the Iranian calendar), 75% of the projected agricultural water-saving measures in Kurdistan Province have been allocated to Qorveh and Dehgolan counties to mitigate the water crisis. However, official reports indicate that this target has not yet been achieved.

In order to attain water-saving goals and ensure the sustainability of agricultural water resources in the region, it is essential to formulate appropriate short-term solutions and long-term strategic interventions. This study has been conducted with the aim of addressing this need.

Research Methodology

This study was conducted within a pragmatic paradigm using a qualitative approach and employing the SWOT strategic analysis technique in a survey format. A questionnaire was used as the primary data collection instrument. The validity and reliability of the questionnaire were confirmed through expert judgment (specialists in water and agriculture) and by calculating Cronbach’s alpha coefficient. The required data were obtained through 98 sub-components related to the internal and external environment of water management. After verifying the accuracy of the collected data, they were entered into SPSS and Excel software for statistical analysis. Strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and threats related to agricultural water management were analyzed using the SWOT framework. Based on the evaluation, weighting, and relative importance of each component, the priority decision-making and policy strategies for improving water consumption were identified.

Sampling Method

Initially, key stakeholders and individuals relevant to the research topic were identified. To enhance the accuracy of responses and obtain reliable information, efforts were made to include participants with the highest level of professional engagement in agricultural and water-related issues within the study area. Accordingly, the sample was selected from managers and specialists in agriculture, water resources, extension services, and planning within local governmental and private organizations. A purposive sampling method was employed, resulting in a statistical sample of 75 individuals, including experts, managers, and leading local farmers.

Findings

Based on the findings, strategies for improving water consumption were positioned within the SWOT matrix-ranked by evaluation score and priority-in the third quadrant (ST: competitive strategy) and the second quadrant (WO: conservative strategy). Among the 14 strategies whose priority and ranking were calculated, seven key strategies were extracted. In order of priority, these are:

Implementation of an adaptive cropping pattern

Formulation of a comprehensive water management plan

Reform of the water allocation model

Development of modern training programs

On-farm water storage

Improvement of farm management

Smart irrigation systems

Conclusion

Based on the research findings, the following conclusions can be drawn:

-Competitive (ST) and conservative (WO) strategies constitute the primary strategic orientations for improving agricultural water consumption in the study area.

-Water management in the region faces significant weaknesses and threats. The most prominent challenges include rising water supply costs to compensate for resource imbalance, recurrent droughts, inefficient water distribution systems, and inadequate farm-level management by farmers. Despite these challenges, there are also existing strengths and opportunities. Through cost–benefit evaluation, either competitive or conservative strategies can be adopted for the target community. The most effective actions within these strategies include: prohibition of water-intensive crops, increasing the mechanization rate, provision of modern training programs, evaluation of the effectiveness of adaptation measures, implementation of incentive mechanisms, and—most importantly—improvement of farm management practices by farmers themselves.

Funding

This research did not receive any specific grant from funding agencies in the public, commercial, or not-for-profit sectors.

Author Contributions

Conceptualization by Khalil Kalantari and Hossein Shabanali Fami; methodology by Khalil Kalantari; Software, data collection, preparation of charts and figures and writing original draft preparation by Soleiman Ghaderi; writing- review, editing, and preparation of English text by Khalil Kalantari; Guidance and supervision by Ali Asadi. All authors have read and approved the final version of the manuscript.

Data Availability Statement

The data that supports the findings of this study are available from the corresponding author.

Acknowledgement

The authors express their sincere gratitude to all individuals who participated in this study.

Ethical Consideration

The authors adhered to ethical research standards and avoided data fabrication, falsification, plagiarism, and any form of research misconduct.

Conflict of Interest

The author declares that there are no conflicts of interest related to this study.

Asadabadi, E. (2019) Formulation or strategy for groundwaters allocation to the agricultural sector in HAMADAN ‌BAHAR aquifer, PH.D thesis, university of Tehran, IRAN. ( in Persian ).
Apostolaki, S. Koundouri, P. Pittis, N. (2019). Using a systemic approach to address the requirement for Integrated Water Resource Management within the Water Framework Directive, Science of the Total Environmenthttps://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2019.05.077.
‌Carlo,E(2023) water scarsity in agriculture: An overview of causes, impacts and approaches for reducing the risks.https://doi.org/10.1016/j.heliyon.2023.18507.
‌ Fagheh Majidi.A & et.al (2022) Investigation the potential and limitations of border counties in attracting and creating economic platforms for the Kurdistan province Management and Planning Organization (in Persian).
‌ Goli.F, Yousefi Mohammadi.M, Movahedi, R. (2017) Agricultural Water Resource Management, First Edition, HAMADAN, Sepehre danesh Publication (in Persian).
‌ Heidari, N. et.al (2019) Approaches and Solutions for adapting to climate change from the aspects of agricultural water management and food security. Journal of water agricultural Management. Volume6, N.1. (in Persian)
‌ IRAN’S Planning and Budget Organization (2019 ) Combination Report of  Studies Land Use Planning, number 1 Report, Third Edition, ( in Persian ).
‌ Iranian Agricultural Ministry (2022) Agricultural Crops  Cultivation Pattern Program of  Kurdistan Province (in Persian).
‌Iranian  Energy Ministry .National Committee of Adaptation to Water Scarcity (2021), Adaptation National Program to Water Scarcity, First Edition, TEHRAN, Energy Ministry Publication.(in Persian)
‌ Kurdistan  Management and Planning  Organization ( 2021 ) Kurdistan province statistical annual  report ,Agricultural  and  fishery sector.( in Persian )
‌Nouri .M, et.al, (2023). Water management dilemma in the agricultural sector of Iran: A review focusing on water governance, Agricultural Water Management. https://doi.org/0100107/j.agwat.91920010001.
‌Official Website of Iran’s Meteorolohical Organozation (2023) the National Drought Center (in Persian).
‌Official Website of Iran’s Meteorolohical Organozation (2026) the National Climatology Center (in Persian).
‌ Parvaz, M. (2022) Water crisis and water resources management requirements, first edition, professor’s publication. Tehran, Iran (in Persian).
‌ Pourgholam‌ Amiji.M & et.al (2024) Smart Irrigation Based on the IOT, Iranian journal of soil and water research.N.9ido. https://doi.org/10.22059/Ijswr.2024.378114.669734
‌ Rao. A.P, Patra. D, Pradhan. A ( 2023 ) ,  Evaluating  reuse of  nontraditional water sources in agriculture and food  production utilizing a scientometrics approach , Journal of Agriculture and Food Research.14,  https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jafr.2023.100858.
‌ Reja, O. Parsinejad, M. Sohrabi, T. (2019) Effectiveness of managerial strategies to reduse of agricultural water consumption in MARVDASHT‌ KHARAME, Journal of Soil and resources Conservation, N.4, Eighth year (in Persian).
Samadi Foroushani.M &et.al (2021) Analysis of Iran’s water Resource Governance System Based on nexus           water‌ food‌ energy, Iran chamber of commerce. Report.N.190757 (in Persian).
‌ Shabanali fami, H. Savari, M. Mohtaghed, M. (2020) Analysis of adaptation strategies of small‌scale farmers to drought condition in ESFAHAN Province, Journal of Spatial Planning and Arrangement, volume24, Issue1.(in Persian).
Zhang. Y, et .al ( 2022 ) Water  Allocation  Management  Under  Scarcity: a Bankruptcy pproach , Water Resources Management, https://doi.org/10.1007/s11269-022-03098-0.